'Harder than people think' - Doncaster Rovers' fan lifts lid on Football Manager researcher role
In many ways, following Doncaster Rovers for the past 25 years has been like a real-life version of Football Manager.
The team has gone through more ups and downs than most clubs, having played in four different divisions thanks to a total of ten promotions and relegations - and there's been the odd trip to Wembley or Cardiff thrown in for good measure, too.
Kieran O'Malley is one of many fans that have been there for it all, having been brought up in a Rovers-supporting family. He caught the bug early and concurs that it's been a rollercoaster in that quarter-century: "Since I started watching them we've gone from the Conference all the way up to the Championship. We just couldn't quite make it to the Premier League, but we've won a few trophies along the way. So, yeah, it's been a good ride so far."
That opening reference to 'FM' - as it is affectionately known - is apt given that Kieran, 30, is the Doncaster Rovers researcher for the hugely successful video game franchise.


So what exactly does that entail? Well, essentially he is the one who the game-makers consult with regards all things Rovers. His reports on individual players predominantly feed into an overall rating system but he also has to keep abreast of player injuries, contracts, even wage demands (more on that later) - and much more.
Kieran, from Rossington, works full-time at a hospital but the role of an FM researcher takes up a fair whack of his time especially through the summer and in the New Year. So how did he get started? "During Covid, I'd get home from work and just go straight on to Football Manager most nights," he tells the Free Press. "I was then scrolling through the Sports Interactive (creators of Football Manager) forums one day and there was a section about research opportunities. So I clicked it, and it said there was an available researcher job for Doncaster Rovers."
A speculative email sent by Kieran was quickly picked up and before he knew it he was on a virtual meeting with the game-makers.
A mammoth spreadsheet acts as his bible, where he documents all manner of stats, notes, injuries and more. When he's at games he's not just there with his Rovers blinkers on - he also has his analytical eyes on too.
"You have to keep track of the transfers, new contracts, injuries and stuff so I do keep a big spreadsheet file," he says. "With transfers, I have to request the transfer details from the club that Rovers are signing the player from." He adds that the only part of this that is "guesswork" is the wage details, an understandably delicate subject. Whilst the financial information relayed in the game for each player is never going to be 100 per cent accurate, Kieran says the head researchers are quick to ensure any glaring errors are revisited.
All other sorts of intricate details are needed such as manager tendencies as Kieran explains: "It can be whether they choose to play the kids in cup games and stuff like rotating their squads. For Donny, it's about what tactics (Grant) McCann likes to play and formations employed regularly."
All that info he feeds in ultimately helps paint a (virtual) picture of Rovers but the thing that sparks the biggest debate, it seems, is a player's attributes.
"I got a bit carried away in the summer, because obviously we'd just won the league," he says. "I sort of thought 'oh I can finally upgrade everyone' but then I had to make a few changes. The head researchers understood why though, thankfully!
"Obviously, I can't give players 20 (that is the top rating for each individual attribute) in everything, because it gets shot down. You have to be realistic. For example, in the summer I upgraded one of Owen Bailey's stats but then the head researchers came back and told me that I'd rated him the same as Declan Rice which is obviously unrealistic.
"Again I was just getting carried away so that was quickly amended. It's a lot harder than people think. I saw on Twitter recently someone said something like 'oh, Rovers are rated badly again and are tipped for relegation' but we have to meet a certain criteria.
"You're always going to get differing opinions. A lot of my mates who are playing the game at the minute are telling me Brandon Hanlan and Toyosi Olusanya are scoring every game. But in real life they're not - it's down to the research work of the teams they've come from. So I'll probably make changes in January to reflect that real-life form.
"It's quite funny because my mate bumped into Luke Molyneux recently and he said to him that I do the attributes for the Rovers squad and Luke said to him 'you need to tell him to make me better!’ It's mad to think a lot of the players are looking at their stats on dribbling, crossing or whatever - and it's come from me."
The FM series has undergone plenty of tweaks in recent years with a gradual change in how players see matches unfold from humble text-based beginnings to dots moving about on a pitch to the present day which looks more like EAFC (formerly FIFA).
To a non-football fan it can seem a bit puzzling as to how people can become so invested, year after year in this type of pastime.
"My girlfriend absolutely hates it! She just can't grasp why I get so annoyed at virtual football, basically," Kieran adds. "But I've played the game for so long and I really, really have a passion for it. So to see my name in the credits is just surreal."