A replay will now take place at the Wham Stadium – likely to be played one week on Tuesday – to determine who progresses to the second round.
Doncaster should have been out of sight after a dominant first half but only had an own goal to show for their efforts after several missed chances.
Shaun Whalley levelled for Accrington after the break before Harrison Biggins put Doncaster back in front.
But it wasn’t to be their day as substitute Seamus Conneely scored late on to get his side back on equal terms.
Scroll down for our player ratings.

9. George Broadbent - 6
Played a huge role in the opener, to his credit. But might have done better with his marking for Accrington's second goal. Photo: Howard Roe/AHPIX LTD

10. Harrison Biggins - 8
Only seems to score screamers. Like his boss said, it was a goal worthy of winning the tie and surely a contender for goal of the competition. Looked a threat all game and showed how dangerous he can be when he gets forward. Photo: HOWARD ROE

11. Luke Molyneux - 7
Missed a great chance for a rare goal a minute after the opener. Once again at the heart of so much of Doncaster's attacking play. If Molyneux can recreate his Hartlepool form in front of goal for Rovers he will be one hell of a player. Photo: HOWARD ROE

12. Mo Faal - 7
Hit the crossbar with an early header but did his best work with his feet by bringing others into play throughout the afternoon. Saw a close-range effort blocked by a fantastic save, not sure he could have done anything else with the finish. Unlucky not to score. Photo: HOWARD ROE


