Senior official admits 'mistakes have been made' by Doncaster Council in old emails on building sale dispute

The 2024 sale of the Doncaster Business Innovation Centre descended into a messy dispute with threats of legal action, emails reveal.

Senior officials at the City of Doncaster Council acknowledged that “mistakes have been made” relating to a messy, ongoing sale of a £630,000 property owned by an arms-length company, in emails obtained by the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS).

The sale of the Doncaster Business Innovation Centre (DBIC) has recently come under scrutiny after it was twice raised with the Mayor of Doncaster, Ros Jones, in the council chamber.

DBIC is currently owned by Arthur Street (Doncaster) Developments Ltd (ASDD), which itself is owned by Doncaster Council, but the building was sold at auction in 2024, but has stalled amid a near-two-year-dispute over VAT.

It is understood the building was purchased at the auction by DBIC Trading Ltd, which Companies House records indicate is owned by local businessman Sanjeev Gug.

The Doncaster Business Innovation Centre as seen from Ten Pound Walk, Doncaster.placeholder image
The Doncaster Business Innovation Centre as seen from Ten Pound Walk, Doncaster. | Google

A spokesperson for DBIC Trading Ltd said it was not in a position to comment because “the matter remains subject to potential legal proceedings”.

Internal emails from August 2024, obtained by the LDRS, have revealed Doncaster Council’s executive director of corporate resources, Debbie Hogg, informed the Mayor, and former cabinet member Councillor Joe Blackham, that the authority would be drafting a letter to Mr Gug acknowledging “mistakes have been made by both parties” in relation to the sale.

This email, sent by Ms Hogg on August 19, 2024, represents an admission by senior staff at the council that it had made a misstep in its handling of the sale.

A City of Doncaster Spokesperson said “Arthur Street (Doncaster) Developments Ltd, a wholly owned company of the Council took DBIC to auction on Tuesday 18th June 2024 and subsequently has been engaging with the buyer to complete the sale.

“It is still the intention to sell this property and as such these discussions are commercial and ongoing. The council has acknowledged that there are lessons to be learnt from this matter.”

Councillor Jason Charity, deputy leader of the Reform UK group on Doncaster Council, has previously raised the sale of the DBIC building twice in the council chamber.

In January 2026, he asked Mayor Jones who authorised the council to lodge a Land Registry Search application on DBIC. These are lodged with the Land Registry in order to protect an organisation’s intended purchase of a property – seemingly frustrating DBIC Trading Ltd’s auction purchase.

ASDD reportedly wrote to DBIC Trading Ltd to distance itself from the council’s decision to apply for the property search.

Mayor Ros Jones has attempted to distance herself from issues surrounding the sale of the DBIC during council meetings.placeholder image
Mayor Ros Jones has attempted to distance herself from issues surrounding the sale of the DBIC during council meetings. | Doncaster Council

The Mayor told Cllr Charity it was a question for the ASDD board, distancing herself of any involvement in the sale.

However, the following month, Cllr Charity claimed, in the chamber, to have a “signed witness statement” from a former cabinet member, now understood to be Cllr Blackham, stating the Mayor had authorised Ms Hogg to “act” on the sale.

He asked Mayor Jones: “What bona fide disposition was the OS1 lodged to protect on August 19, 2024, and importantly, who authorised it?”

As previously reported by the LDRS, Cllr Charity’s question did not receive an answer in the chamber and was edited out of the video recording of the meeting uploaded to the council’s YouTube channel.

Debbie Hogg, executive director of corporate resources at Doncaster Council.placeholder image
Debbie Hogg, executive director of corporate resources at Doncaster Council. | Doncaster Council

A spokesperson for the council said at the time: “The question at council identified a council officer and referred to a contentious commercial matter involving both the council and third parties. It is inappropriate to name officers as they do not have a right of reply in the meeting in the same manner as another councillor may have.”

The same emails released to the LDRS under the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act 2000 revealed the council had been taking legal advice on the sale, prior to the acknowledgement that the council had made a “mistake”.

The FOI request did not uncover any emails from Mayor Jones instructing or authorising senior officers to “act” on the sale, though some information was redacted or not released in the FOI as it was deemed by the council to be exempt.

The emails also revealed, however, that Cllr Blackham had warned Mayor Jones on August 14, 2024, that the council’s dispute with DBIC Trading Ltd for VAT on the DBIC sale could lead to “serious litigation with nasty media coverage”.

Joe Blackham, was previously the cabinet member for Highways, Infrastructure and Enforcement at Doncaster Council.placeholder image
Joe Blackham, was previously the cabinet member for Highways, Infrastructure and Enforcement at Doncaster Council. | Local Library

Eight days later, on August 22, 2024, Cllr Blackham forwarded an email, which was redacted in the release, to the Mayor, Ms Hogg and the chief executive Damian Allen, stating the issue was “traveling in a direction I certainly would not/could not condone”

He said his earlier warnings of a legal battle were going to “materialise with a vengeance” and added: “A modicum of common sense goes a long way it appears to me the time is long overdue to use it.”

Earlier, on August 20, 2024, Cllr Blackham had asked Ms Hogg if the council intended to reach a “compromise position” with DBIC Trading Ltd, but was informed that doing so was not one of the three options the council had before them.

The LDRS has approached former councillor Joe Blackham in relation to this story.

News you can trust since 1925
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice