A total of 10 fire engines tackled a blaze at Morris Metals, recycling site in Balby Carr Bank, which broke out shortly before 7pm.
South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue (SYFR) said investigators had recorded the cause of the fire as accidental.
This was not the first time the recycling plant had been involved in a fire as they had suffered similar devastating blazes in February this year and April last year.
Their attendance was reduced to two fire engines by Saturday morning and people living in the area were advised to avoid the area.
SYFR worked alongside partner agencies including Nottingham and West Yorkshire fire and rescue services and the Environment Agency in its response to the incident.
They left the scene on Saturday evening after making sure no hot spots were developing.