Dunscroft United surrendered a 3-0 interval lead when suffering a 4-2 defeat on penalties – after it had finished 4-4 after extra-time - in their Doncaster Rovers Senior League Premier Division Cup final against Kinsley Boys.
Goals by Ashley Cantrill and Daniel White secured FC Graceholme a 2-1 Premier Division win at Rossington Main.
Graceholme (Craig Dyson, Daniel White) had lost 3-2 at Sutton Rovers, for whom Adrian Parker (2) and Ryan Walker netted, on Thursday night.
Leaders Sutton had won 4-1 at Brodsworth Welfare (Wallace Brown) 48 hours earlier on the back of goals by Adam Baskerville, Ryan Walker and sub Darren Smith.
Hemsworth Elite retained top spot in Division One with a 5-1 win over Yorkshire Main.
The West Yorkshire side had also beaten Balby Recreational by the odd goal in seven in midweek.
Denaby United Academy climbed above Askern into second place after dishing out a 6-2 beating to their title rivals.
Academy had been held to a 4-4 midweek draw by Doncaster Deaf Trust in midweek.
Andy Reay notched a hat trick for the home side with Alister Dalziel also chipping in.
Nathan Lovell (2), Danny Moutrey and Joshua Haines replied for Denaby.
n Swinton Athletic will face Houghton Main in the final of the Dawson & Burgess Doncaster & District FA Challenge Cup at the Keepmoat Stadium on Friday, May 20 (7.30pm).